Roof Repair vs. Roof Replacement – Know the Difference


What’s the major differences between roof repair and replacement? The roof is an integral part of any residential or commercial building. It creates a barrier from harsh weather elements and keeps building interiors from deteriorating. Most North American roofs can last for over 20 years with regular maintenance. But wear-and-tear and unexpected natural events can cause significant roof damage.

Deciding whether to repair or replace your roof can be difficult when it gets damaged. However, an experienced roofing contractor can help you make a choice. Read on to learn what’s involved in roof replacement and repair.

Roof Repair

A roof repair is sufficient when the damage to your roof is mild or moderate. Roof repair can restore your roofing system and even extend the lifespan of an aging roof. Irrespective of how minor the roof damage is, contact a professional roofing company near you to ensure the roof gets appropriately fixed.

Roof repair projects involve working on an isolated roof section instead of the entire roof. Patching up holes and tiny gaps or replacing damaged or missing shingles and other components could be necessary during restoration. Before you can fix your roof, a professional roofer will help identify the problem through a complete inspection.

Handle roofing issues with urgency to avoid costly damage later. Look for signs of wear, such as missing or damaged shingles, nail pops, holes, granule loss, or cracked flashing.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Roof Repair

A roof repair project isn’t always the best choice in all scenarios. We’ve broken down some of the advantages and disadvantages of roof repairs.


Benefits of roof repair include:

  • Affordability.
  • Short completion time.
  • Extended roof lifespan.


Here are some cons of repairing the roof:

  • It may be challenging to match shingle colors with original pieces.
  • Poor workmanship can cause further issues.
  • A repair can hide underlying issues.

Roof Replacement

Replacing a roof involves replacing the entire visible roof area. Professional roofers often have to strip off all roofing to expose the deck before installing the new roof. Most replacement projects also include repairs to rafters, trusses, and sheathing.

Because of the extensive nature of a roof replacement, the initial cost is typically higher than that of a roof repair. New roofs are an investment, but there are cases where they save you costs. If your roof has been damaged by a natural disaster such as a tornado, hail, or high winds, you should contact your insurer to discuss your options for getting it fixed or replaced.

When you see your roof sagging, you should consider replacing it. Sagging is a severe issue that indicates your roof is about to collapse.

Replacing a roof is lengthy and involves more work and time than repairing a roof. During the inspection, a roofer will examine the damage and decide if a patch job is feasible or if a complete replacement is necessary.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Roof Replacement

Roof replacement is an intensive home improvement project with unique pros and cons


Benefits of roof replacement:

  • Replacement is a comprehensive project that covers all roofing issues.
  • New roofs boost curb appeal and property value.
  • They increase energy efficiency.
  • Roof replacements last longer than repairs.


Below are the top disadvantages of roof replacement:

  • Replacing a roof takes considerable time.
  • It is costlier than repairs.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Roof Replacement and Repair

Home improvement projects need ample consideration for success and timely completion. Unlike painting a room or refinishing your woodwork, fixing or replacing your roof is a significant project that requires careful planning. You must choose the proper process to get the best value for money and keep your roof in good shape.

You wouldn’t want to replace roof shingles only to discover a more severe underlying issue. If minor repairs can solve the problem, there is no need to pull down the whole roof. Below are the top considerations you should consider before settling on a solution for your roofing problem.

  • How Old is Your Roof?

Although roofs are durable, they all have a lifespan. The age of a roof may be an indicator of its need for replacement. Asphalt shingles often last for two decades, while clay tiles and metal roofs have longer lifespans.

The replacement may be necessary if your roof has aged noticeably, suffered storm damage, has leaks, or has any other severe issues. Whether you plan to stay in your house for the next few decades or want to sell it, replacing an older roof may be more cost-effective than making frequent, costly repairs.

  • The Extent of Roof Damage

If you’re debating whether to repair or replace your roof, it’s likely that your roof has a deteriorated appearance or suffered physical damage. Working with a reputable roofing contractor will help you to understand the extent of any roof damage. This will allow you to make the best choice for your house.

Signs of roof damage vary widely depending on the type of roofing material. They include:

  • Worn down roofing materials.
  • Dark streaks or moss between roofing materials.
  • Cupped shingle edges.
  • Bald spots on the asphalt.
  • Cracked or broken tiles or shingles.
  • Dented roofing components.
  • Rusted components.
  • Is Your Roof Leaky?

Leaking roofs are among the top causes of roof repairs and roof replacement. A leaking roof could cause water stains across ceilings and walls. The origin of a roof leak isn’t always easy to pinpoint, but a roofing contractor can help diagnose the issue.

It’s best to address a leaking roof as quickly as possible, regardless of its cause, because even a little leak can escalate to more severe issues, such as damaged insulation, framing, and ceilings.

  • Budget

The project cost is one of the most critical factors for property owners to consider when deciding between a reroof and a roof repair. Roof repairs generally are less expensive than a complete replacement. However, if you make multiple repairs for several years, you may spend more than you would have on a new roof.

A roof replacement may cost more initially, but it saves money in the long run by eliminating the need for future repairs. If you have valuables stored under your roof, a new roof might provide you some much-needed peace of mind that they are safe from the elements. Your roofing company can give you estimates for either project to help you make an informed decision.

Consult the Professionals

If you’re having roofing problems, give us a call to schedule an inspection so that we may take a look at your roof, determine its current status, and provide a solution tailored to your specific needs.

Consulting a professional roofing company is the best approach to solving roof issues. Call us at +18649904836 for queries or clarification when scheduling an inspection.

Latest Posts